Well, the most romantic movie ever is now out on DVD. Naturally, I’m talking about the movie Mr. and Mrs. Smith. You’re not sure that a movie about two assassins who find out five or six years into their marriage that their spouse is also an assassin is romantic? Because they spend about half the movie trying to kill each other? Because after trying to shoot each other, blow each other up, and drop elevators on one another they end up in a martial arts/gun battle which culminates in their house blowing up?
I don’t see why you should hold that against the movie.
My previous “most romantic movie ever” was a tie between two John Wayne and Maureen O’Hara movies: The Quiet Man and McLintock. In The Quiet Man, right after getting married John Wayne and Maureen O’Hara have this huge fight. This results in her telling him that she’ll “clean the house, and keep the land”, but that she won’t have sex with him until he beats up her brother. The climatic finish of the movie begins with him dragging her 5 miles on foot, “just a good stretch of the legs”, back to her brother’s house after she tries to leave him. John Wayne throws her at her brother’s feet and tells the brother that if he doesn’t cough up the dowry, he can have his sister back.
The brother coughs up the dowry, and a sucker punch. Just when you think a fist fight is about to break out, the fist fight you’ve been waiting for the whole movie, Maureen O’Hara interrupts to tell John Wayne that “supper will be waitin’ for ya” and walks off as proud as can be. Later, she welcomes both husband and brother home for supper when they come in drunk as well, Irishmen who’ve just had a fist fight.
They don’t make movies like that any more.
In McLintock, Maureen O’Hara and John Wayne bicker through the entire movie plus he drinks a lot. In that climatic finish, he chases her through the entire town while everyone looks on and cheers. When he catches her, he gives her a good spanking, with a rather scary looking shovel provided by her daughter and prospective son-in-law.
They don’t make movies like that either.
In case you haven’t guessed, not only am I part Irish, but I’m married to a woman who’s even more Irish then I am. I’ve made a careful study of all those movies that other people find “romantic” and I’ve discovered two things:
One, they’re right about 9 1/2 Weeks. Though come to think of it, there’s spanking in that movie too. Quite a bit actually. Hmmm…. And I wouldn’t call it romantic, per se. Rather, watching it with someone you love is romantic, but the movie isn’t really romantic, they break up at the end. (I know, half of you have never gotten all the way through to the end of the movie when you’ve watched it together. Well, sorry to burst your bubble but that’s what happens.)
Two, the rest of you must be total pansies. Or none of you are Irish, which is the same thing really.
I don’t think its just the Irish who think that fighting is part of love, romance and marriage. I mean what idiot in Hollywood came up with this idea that love and romance is all sweetness and light? That’s got to be the biggest load of well-meaning-but-ultimately-stupid-nonsense I’ve ever heard. I have news for you all: If you agree with your loved one 100% of the time, you’re with the wrong person; you married yourself.
I really think Hollywood is doing our generation a disservice by portraying all married couples as never fighting. Think back on every sitcom or movie you’ve seen in the last 20 years. Did any of those people ever have one of those top-of-your-lungs, break-the-dishes, scare-the-pets, duck-because-you-have-to kind of fights that you’ve had with your loved one? No, right?
I’ve had several friends of mine tell me that they were surprised to find out that me and my wife fought. Well of course we fight. We’re married. Fights and power struggles are as much a part of being married as rings.
Some people have told me that they don’t like these movies because they feel John Wayne “dominates” Maureen O’Hara. Now granted, these movies seem to portray what we’ve come to call a “traditional” relationship where the man is supposed to be the “head of the household”, and this is supposedly demeaning to women. Though if you think that Maureen O’Hara was ever dominated by John Wayne in a movie, you must have gone to the bathroom during the good parts.
Besides, my wife tells me she and I have a traditional relationship, and if you think that means I’m charge, well, you’re an idiot. I may be the “head” of the household, but she’s definitely the “heart”, and what that really means is that I’m in charge of certain things, things I happen to be good at, and she’s in charge of other things, things she’s good at. It’s really all about partnership, and covering your partner’s weaknesses with your strengths. All the people I know in “traditional relationships” have divided up responsibilities that way; and the division between “head” and “heart” is different for each of them. To quote my favorite feminist Camile Paglia: “sex is complicated”. The people who talk the most about “modern” vs. “traditional” relationships all seem to be single. All the married people I know don’t care, they just wish it was the other persons job to do the dishes.
McLintock is romantic because even though these two people are having a bad moment in their marriage, you also see how much they’ve accomplished as a couple. As John Wayne puts it: “All that growin’ together”. You know that the marriage of two people who have been through as much as they have will survive. The Quiet Man isn’t really about the fist fight, its about two people from very different cultures learning to communicate their needs. Mr. and Mrs. Smith is really about being honest with your spouse and about working together as a couple on the challenges of life. Granted most of us don’t have to fight off 50 ninjas, but think of them as 50 bill collectors and I think it applies to everyone. What makes these movies romantic to my way of thinking is that they are all about couples who have problems, and overcome them. That’s true romance. Or at least Irish Romance.
So this Valentine’s Day, think back on a few fights you’ve had with your loved one, and smile.